FantasySCOTUS Case Tracker
Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons
| Total Numer of Predictions: | 119 |
| Votes to Affirm: | 54 |
| Votes to Reverse: | 65 |
| Percent Affirm: | 45.38% |
| Percent Reverse: | 54.62% |
| FantasySCOTUS Prediction: | Reverse |
| Outcome: | Reverse |
| Member | Ranking | Roberts | Scalia | Kennedy | Thomas | Ginsburg | Breyer | Alito | Sotomayor | Kagan | Prediction | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Member | Ranking | Roberts | Scalia | Kennedy | Thomas | Ginsburg | Breyer | Alito | Sotomayor | Kagan | Prediction | |
 | Melech | 1 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| bannana873 | 2 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| nbcrcc | 3 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| corteal | 4 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse |
| eodenius | 5 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| wah38 | 6 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| amibel | 7 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| fosca | 8 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| wah38team | 9 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| greennc939 | 10 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| kmpsca | 11 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| mattnoller | 12 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| lwyrup | 13 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| tagast8872 | 14 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| tmpour | 15 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| zag7 | 16 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| kmsosebee | 17 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse |
| femmesansparfum | 18 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| xtrapjawx | 19 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| drewberslondy | 20 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| ccorn825 | 21 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| mhelzein | 22 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse |
| simoncowell | 23 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| crwelling | 24 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| djenkins5 | 25 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| TennJake | 26 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| cmdoran1 | 27 | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| prestonday | 28 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| TheDuke | 29 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| David.Disler | 30 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| alaskanpike | 31 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| sutton197 | 32 | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| theprez98 | 33 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| armartin | 34 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| tug8 | 35 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| jrg2174 | 36 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| TabC2002 | 37 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| jcm5653 | 38 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| Christopher.Staley | 39 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| pieVdelta | 40 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| zphillipps | 41 | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| mdebush | 42 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| estreisel | 43 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| sammy899 | 44 | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| jwayment | 45 | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm |
| matt4684 | 46 | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse |
| kgrabo2 | 47 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| haldo100 | 48 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| rskelto1 | 49 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| narcher007 | 50 | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| zhilton | 51 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| wfgodbold | 52 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Recuse | Reverse |
| NVknucklehead | 53 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| advokat | 54 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| edgesector5 | 56 | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| newm2930 | 57 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| joeybara | 58 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| stephers1987 | 59 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| nkn22 | 60 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| tani8988 | 61 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| strong.d | 65 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| michaelh | 66 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| Torinir | 67 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| ladytigerette | 70 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| aclowther | 71 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| Kanu17 | 72 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| Obamanomicon | 73 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse |
| lhht7 | 74 | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| MGodRN | 75 | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| mse326 | 77 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| CodeJPG | 78 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| ballaholla | 79 | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| Jakes553 | 80 | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| gomorra3 | 81 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| aedling01 | 82 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Recuse | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| greghuffaker | 83 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| ibrahimelshamy | 84 | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| RogerStark | 85 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| loveslaaw | 87 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| fernandos | 88 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm |
| L_M_Brown | 90 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| spade013 | 93 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| goodfella1098 | 94 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| TARehman | 95 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| bhrusty | 96 | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| trust40 | 101 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| davidfett | 104 | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| KielG | 106 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse |
| BreyerRabbit | 108 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| tbecvar | 109 | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| boundedrationality | 110 | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| afcsorba | 115 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| sbeach27 | 116 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| pouliotalvarez | 117 | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| atgrano | Unranked | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| CGBourj | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm |
| DevinWatkins | Unranked | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| ds52075 | Unranked | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| exteric | Unranked | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| faussettesq | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| fluxion | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| gkclarkson | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| IHearDeadPeopleJustLikeScalia | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| jhoberer | Unranked | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse |
| jlbyellin | Unranked | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| Lucille Bluth | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| MarshallLaw | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| mhyuen000 | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| Old Soldier | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| Schwarzy | Unranked | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse |
| sjackson | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| smith.jason.william | Unranked | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| Steamluv | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Affirm |
| Stewey005 | Unranked | Reverse | Affirm | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| STMAHouse | Unranked | Reverse | Affirm | Affirm | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse | Reverse |
| thelongarm | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| themaxnathanson | Unranked | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm | Affirm |
| Justice Affirm | 63 | 75 | 50 | 75 | 54 | 38 | 69 | 38 | 43 | - | ||
| Justice Reverse | 54 | 42 | 67 | 42 | 63 | 79 | 47 | 79 | 73 | - | ||
| Justice Affirm % | 53.8% | 64.1% | 42.7% | 64.1% | 46.2% | 32.5% | 59.0% | 32.5% | 36.8% | - | ||
| Justice Reverse % | 46.2% | 35.9% | 57.3% | 35.9% | 53.8% | 67.5% | 40.2% | 67.5% | 62.4% | - |